It basically was just a revision of the old articles. Dec 12, 2019 the new jersey plan was a proposal for the structure of the united states federal government, presented by william paterson at the constitutional convention of 1787. Dec 07, 2015 this is a plan of government proposed by william patterson from the state of new jersey. How would you compare and contrast the virginia plan and. Learning objectives compare and contrast the virginia plan, the new jersey plan, and the connecticut compromise regarding the revision of the articles of confederation. Difference between the virginia plan an the new jersey. What are the differences between the virginia and new. In the constitutional convention, the virginia plan favored large states while the new jersey plan favored small states. This position reflected the belief that the states were independent entities. The great compromise of 1787 combined the virginia plan and new jersey plan by creating a bicameral legislature. The virginia plan, new jersey plan, and the great compromise. Why is the virginia plan better than the new jersey plan.
A bicameral legislature every state had two members in the senate house of representatives was filled by population each five. Honors constitution projectlance shepherd created using powtoon free sign up at create animated videos and animated. Virginia plan each state receives a certain number of representatives based on population. Dec 22, 2019 the new jersey plan, which william paterson proposed to the constitutional convention, illustrated a unicameral legislation consisting of a single congressional legislative body in which each state would have an equal number of representatives. Virginia plan, new jersey plan, and connecticut plan.
The virginia plan was used, but some ideas from the new jersey plan were added. Zoeller explains the virginia plan, the new jersey plan, and the great compromise that took place during the constitutional convention. Did george washington support the new jersey plan or the virginia plan. The new jersey plan provided for equal state representation in congress unlike the virgina plan that was based on population. How did the great compromise of 1787 combine parts from the. Connecticut compromise the connecticut compromise was a combination of the virginia and new jersey plans it called for. Nov 03, 2014 virginia plan, new jersey plan, connecticut compromise, 35ths clause nathan kellogg. A bicameral legislature every state had two members in the senate house of representatives was filled by. Upon seeing a favorable new jersey focus group response to. Edmund randolph of virginia proposed what would be called the virginia plan.
Which plan is better for the united states, the virginia plan or the new jersey plan. These plans were proposed when a group of state delegates gathered at the constitutional convention in 1787. How did the great compromise of 1787 combine parts from. How did the great compromise of 1787 combine parts from the virginia plan and the new jersey plan. Facts about the virginia plan for kids, children, homework and schools.
The new jersey plan was a proposal for the structure of the united states federal government, presented by william paterson at the constitutional convention of 1787. What are the similarities between new jersey plan and. Government divided into 3 branches executive, legislative and judicial 4. Plan, alternately called the new jersey plan or the paterson plan, proposed on june 15, 1787. Start learning today with flashcards, games and learning tools all for free. Virginia plan, new jersey plan, connecticut compromise, 35ths clause nathan kellogg. Ultimately, the new jersey plan was rejected as a basis for a new constitution. I need to know if george washington supported the virginia plan or the new jersey plan for a report. The smaller states opposed the virginia plan presented by james madison because they feared that it would allow the more populous states to dominate the government. The key feature of pattersons proposal was giving equal power to. What are the differences between the virginia and new jersey. Great compromise of 1787 during the summer of 1787, delegates to the constitutional convention in philadelphia debated on what type of legislative body the new national government of the united states should have. How to fix forward head posture 3 easy exercises from a chiropractor.
After two weeks of debating the virginia plan, a counterproposal was put forth by william patterson, which has become known as the new jersey plan or the small state plan or the patterson plan. The new jersey plan constitution of united states of. Jan 06, 2012 compare and contrast the virginia plan, the new jersey plan, and the connecticut plancontrast their fundamental ideas and explain the influence each had on the design of the modern american legislature. Lee atwater and roger ailes worked on the campaign as george h. The virginia plan and the new jersey plan flashcards quizlet. This position reflected the belief that the states were independent entities and as they entered the united states of america freely and individually, so they remained. It had a house of represenative where the number of representatives was based. The list of changes was drafted by james madison and presented to the convention by the governor of virgina, edmund randolph.
The constitutional convention boundless political science. The federalists wanted a strong government and strong executive branch. The document was a response to the virginia plan, which would have given proportional power to the states based on their number of citizens. This created a conflict with representation between bigger states, who wanted control befitting their population, and smaller states, who didnt want to be bullied by larger states. In 1787, delegates met to reflect on the failings of government and to scrap the articles of confederation to focus. Want to find crash course elsewhere on the internet. To get a better understanding of the origins of the u. Pattersons ideas amounted to no more than a simple reshaping of the articles of confederation. This plan called for a bicameral two house legislature. The new jersey plan was debated for four days, but the larger states rejected it. Did george washington support the new jersey plan or the. The following text was taken from the avalon projects reproduction of madisons notes from the convention. It briefly formulated 15 resolutions that should define the powers and structure of the national government. The virginia plan is not better for the united states because the smaller states citizens would not have as much power.
The new jersey plan provided for equal state representation in. Mix, from the people for one house, from the states for the other. The plan was created in response to the virginia plan. Virginianew jersey plan venn diagram by andrew aragon.
The plan was submitted before the congress by the head of the virginia delegation, governor edmund randolph, on may 29, 1787. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Oct 16, 2012 imagine you are a delegate from virginia and you are giving a speech to convince the other delegates at the constitutional convention that the adoption of the virginia plan is necessary. The plan was created in response to the virginia plan, which called for two houses of congress, both elected with apportionment according to. Difference between the virginia plan an the new jersey plan. The new jersey plan was a proposed government for the united states developed by william paterson in 1787. This was a plan that was not based off of populations. A compromise was reached yesterday june 29th, 1787 in philadelphia combining the new jersey plan and the virginia plan.
American government summer 2011 compare and contrast the virginia plan, the new jersey plan, and the connecticut plan contrast their fundamental ideas and explain the influence each had on the design of the modern american legislature. Virginia plan, new jersey plan, connecticut compromise, 35ths clause duration. The text is largely unaltered as presented here, but. In terms of congressional representation, the new jersey plan proposed a unicameral house, which would allow all states equal representation while the virginia plan vouched for a bicameral house that would have the house of representatives elected by people and the senate that would be elected by state legislatures foner 257.
Compare and contrast the virginia and new jersey plans. Ratification of the constitution boundless political science. This system would split legislators into two houses, as opposed to the single assembly put forth by the new jersey plan. Start studying the virginia plan and the new jersey plan. William peterson of new jersey presented the plan to the convention on june 15, 1787. Get an answer for how would you compare and contrast the virginia plan and the new jersey plan in a diagram. The virginia plan and the new jersey plan were two proposals on how to restructure the american form of government. And who knows, maybe all this talk of compromise will even inspire craig and eagle to. The virginia plan also known as the randolph plan, after its sponsor, or the largestate plan was a proposal by virginia delegates during the united states constitutional convention for a bicameral legislative branch. Explain to the delegates why the new jersey plan is the best way to fix the government of the united states. Virginia plan, new jersey plan and the great compromise. What was the differences between the virginia plan and the. On june 15th, 1787 the virginia plan was countered by the new jersey plan, also called the paterson plan or the small state plan.
William paterson proposed the new jersey, or small state, plan, which provided for equal representation in congress. The new jersey plan also known as the small state plan or the paterson plan was a proposal for the structure of the united states government presented by william paterson at the constitutional convention on june 15, 1787. This created a conflict with representation between bigger states, who wanted control befitting their population, and smaller. Under the virginia plan, a state like virginia would have had a much greater say in congress than smaller new jersey since virginia had. Sep 09, 2012 the great compromise of 1787 combined the virginia plan and the new jersey plan by creating a bicameral legislature. It retained proportional representation in the legislature. The plan was drafted by james madison while he waited for a quorum to assemble at the constitutional convention of 1787. Learning objectives compare and contrast the virginia plan, the new jersey plan, and the connecticut compromise regarding the revision of. The new jersey plan has a unicameral government one house and the virginia plan has a bicameral government two houses. The small states therefore proposed the new jersey plan. William patterson proposed the new jersey plan as a response to the virginia plan. The virginia plan suggested first and foremost that the united states govern by way of a bicameral legislature. The final result of the debates between the virginia and new jersey plan was the great compromise connecticut compromise that was a combination of both plans.
Resolved, that the articles of confederation ought to be so corrected and enlarged as to accomplish the objects proposed by their institution, namely common defence, security of liberty and general welfare. Dec 17, 2018 the virginia plan suggested first and foremost that the united states govern by way of a bicameral legislature. Mar 25, 2009 did george washington support the new jersey plan or the virginia plan. The virginia plan wants representation in congress to be based on population. Constitution, read the lesson titled new jersey plan vs.
The virginia plan was drafted by james madison and evaluated during the. Quizlet makes simple learning tools that let you study anything. Patterson2 laid before the convention the plan which he said several of the deputations wished to be substituted in place of that proposed by mr. New jersey plan opposite of the virginia plan, it proposed a singlechamber congress in which each state had one vote. The smaller states would benefit from this plan because there would be equal representation for all states for the two houses. It is tempting to speculate why hamilton spent so much time on his eleven point plan and what impact he had.
It had a house of represenative where the number of representatives was based on the states population. Virginia plan, new jersey plan, connecticut compromise, 3. In 1787, delegates met to reflect on the failings of government and to scrap the articles of confederation to focus on starting over. How to summarize the virginia plan and the new jersey plan. The difference between the new jersey plan and the virginia plan is the former proposed equal state representation in congress and the latter proposed state representation be determined by population. This system would split legislators into two houses, as opposed to the single assembly put forth by the new jersey plan, and legislators would be held to specified term limits. Though it included provisions that the larger states would never agree to, it reasserted the smaller states position. New jersey plan each state receives an equal number of.
The result of the vote was 73 in favor of the virginia plan. The new jersey plan because it purposed a better stand point meaning national government and state. Derived from the people and based on popular representation. Please practice handwashing and social distancing, and check out our resources for adapting to these times. Virginia plan, new jersey plan, and the connecticut plan. The differences between the new jersey and the virginia plan, and what became known as the connecticut plan or great compromise.
One bit of american mythology has hamilton deliberately introducing such an outrageous plan in order to make the virginia rather than the new jersey plan look moderate. The new jersey plan proposed that each state have an equal number of delegates, thus favoring smaller states with fewer people. The virginia plan called for two houses based on representation and that would have nullified the power of the smaller states. Also the new jersey focus was to make all states to have equal representation regardless on. Under the new jersey plan, the unicameral legislature with one vote per state was inherited from the articles of confederation. It was presented to the convention on may 29, 1787. How would you compare and contrast the virginia plan.
Patersons goal was to create a plan that ensured small states would have a voice in the national legislature. The debates over the virginia plan and the new jersey plan lasted from may 29th to june 14th, 1787, when a vote was taken. What were the three main provisions of the new jersey plan. The new jersey plan is the better plan for the united states. What are the differences between the virginia and new jersey plans.
628 1077 1615 1354 76 751 293 370 542 433 1323 1184 718 967 493 49 299 536 538 1652 347 1000 706 1485 494 1110 903 1002 701 992 254 62